A San Jose Neighbor Sued to Stop an Autistic Boy’s Noises in His Own Backyard. A Jury Awarded His Family $8 Million Instead.
A Santa Clara County jury has awarded $8 million to the family of Ezequiel “Zeke” Arvayo, a San Jose boy with Level 3 autism, after a neighbor sued to stop the sounds he made in the backyard of the home his family rented. The neighbor’s own claim failed. The jury ruled for the family on their cross-complaint, and NBC Bay Area reported the verdict on Oct. 29, 2026.
The Lawsuit Over a Boy’s Backyard Noises
Zeke lived with his mother, Serena Arvayo, and his grandfather in a rented house on Boynton Avenue. According to the California Post report carried on Yahoo News, Zeke is nonverbal, was diagnosed with Level 3 autism at age 2, and is cared for full-time by his mother, a single parent.
The next-door neighbor sued the family and their landlord in December 2023, seeking a “public nuisance abatement” and a restraining order. The California Post reported that her complaint called the boy’s behavior “indecent” and “offensive,” said he would “wail and scream for hours, often without adult supervision,” and claimed the noise interfered with her work from home, harmed her career and business and reduced her enjoyment of her property. Court records also show she texted the landlord about the boy making “strange noises.”
NBC Bay Area reported that the neighbor said Zeke’s backyard grunting was a nuisance that hurt her property value and caused her emotional distress. Serena Arvayo told the station the label was “very hurtful.”
The Family’s Cross-Complaint and the $8 Million Verdict
The Arvayos filed their cross-complaint in March 2024. The neighbor’s public nuisance claim was dismissed in September, the California Post reported, and the jury then decided the family’s claim. It awarded $8 million for intentional infliction of emotional distress.
The family’s attorneys said Zeke goes to school and therapy on weekdays, plays with bubbles in the backyard on weekend afternoons, and was never left unsupervised. They described his vocal stimming as an expression of joy. The family also says the neighbor approached Serena before the case began, complained about Zeke and asked that he stop playing in the backyard. Their attorneys wrote that she asked, in front of the boy, whether there was a cure for his condition.
The Arvayos later moved out of the rental, even though their new home costs more. Attorney Ron Rossi told NBC Bay Area the verdict “sends a message to people that think they can get away with bad behavior.” Attorney Rachael Boden told KRON4, as quoted by the California Post, that the jury “understood the struggles” of the Arvayo family and that the boy’s sounds are not a nuisance in a civilized society. Boden said the award will help pay for security and assistance for the boy. The neighbor’s attorney did not respond to requests for comment from either outlet.
What Level 3 Autism and Vocal Stimming Mean
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s autism diagnosis guidance rates severity on three levels, and Level 3 is the one that “requires very substantial support.” The same criteria list repetitive speech and movements among the features clinicians look for.
Repeated sounds are often a form of self-regulation. Developmental pediatrician Dr. Carrie Cuffman told Cleveland Clinic that stimming is a behavior of repeating an action or making a sound that helps a person regulate their own feelings. The clinic’s article says stimming is usually harmless and does not typically need medical treatment.
How California Defines a Nuisance
The neighbor’s suit rested on nuisance law. Under California Civil Code section 3479, anything injurious to health, indecent or offensive, or that obstructs the use of property can qualify as a nuisance. That claim was dismissed before the jury heard the family’s case. The jury’s award came on the family’s separate claim for intentional infliction of emotional distress.
Get stories like this by email. Sign up for The Parent Diaries Letter.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Will Buckner – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons
