Two mugs of hot cocoa on a table

Danielle Hand’s Kids Watched Classmates Eat Cake and Drink Hot Chocolate. The Treat Was Only for Students With Perfect Attendance.

On the last school day before the October half-term break, some children in two classrooms at a primary school in Doncaster, England, got cake or a cookie and a hot chocolate or milkshake. Brooklyn-Harper Bond, 7, and her brother Michael-James Kendall, 5, sat and watched.

The treat was only for students with 100% attendance since the school year began in September, their mother, Danielle Hand, told the SWNS news agency in a story published Nov. 10. Hand, a 30-year-old self-employed carer and mother of three, says she only learned about it when her kids came home and told her.

Six Days, Five Days and a Family Trip

Brooklyn had missed six days of school and had 91% attendance, according to Hand. Michael had missed five days and had 93%. Some of Michael’s absences were authorized, including an eye test and a doctor’s appointment.

Hand also says the absences included a four-day family holiday in the U.K., which counted as unauthorized. She acknowledges that taking the trip was her decision and her responsibility. Her argument is that her children should not be singled out for a choice they had no part in.

She says Brooklyn and a couple of other children in her class were left out. Michael told her four other children in his class also missed the treat, though Hand believes he may not have been given one partly because he is in a lower key stage.

A Mom’s Post Viewed More Than a Million Times

Hand says she was never told about the attendance reward and that the school had done similar things before, including holding back lunchtime ice pops in the summer and taking children out of class for Halloween and Christmas banquets. She says Brooklyn, who is being tested for autism, was very upset.

She wrote about it on Facebook, and her post was viewed more than a million times. “Attendance should not be used as a weapon to not reward a child,” she told SWNS.

Hand has filed a formal complaint. The school has opened an internal investigation and agreed to meet with her. She also contacted Ofsted, the agency that inspects schools in England, and her member of Parliament, Ed Miliband, who wrote back that he had noted her concerns and encouraged her to raise them with the school. She has started a petition to end attendance rewards.

What the School’s Trust Says

The school is run by Outwood Grange Academies Trust, an exempt charity based in Wakefield, West Yorkshire. A trust spokesperson told SWNS the matter is being reviewed by the school’s principal under its complaints procedure and declined to comment further. Ofsted had not responded to SWNS by the time the story was published.

Why English Schools Push So Hard on Attendance

Attendance is a major focus for schools in England. The Department for Education’s guidance, Working Together to Improve School Attendance, became statutory in August 2024. It sets out what schools, academy trusts and local authorities must do to keep attendance high and to support students who are persistently absent.

The government’s page on school attendance and absence says a child can miss school only if they are too ill to attend or the school has given permission in advance. It says a holiday is generally not considered an exceptional circumstance, and that parents who take children out during term time can be fined or face legal action.

That puts families like Hand’s in a familiar bind: the rules on absence are aimed at parents, but a classroom reward lands on the child. Parent Diaries has followed other parents pushing back on school decisions, including Briana Winkle, whose nonverbal son cried at the sight of the school bus.

For now, Hand is waiting on her meeting with the school. Her position has not changed since the day her kids came home without a treat: a child’s attendance record should not decide who gets a slice of cake.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Personal Creations – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons

Similar Posts