A Woman Placed With Carprice Williams at 14 Says She Was Locked in a Bedroom, and Philadelphia’s DA Opens a New Investigation Into Malayshia Alford’s Death
The Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office announced on Nov. 12 that it is opening an independent investigation into the care and death of 10-year-old Malayshia Alford. The announcement came the same week a former foster child came forward with allegations about the home where Malayshia lived. Her foster mother, Carprice Williams, is charged with murder, and the allegations below have not been tested in court.
The new investigation is separate from the criminal case against Williams. It covers the systems around a child in foster care, and it follows the first charges announced earlier in the month.
What the district attorney announced
According to a press release from the District Attorney’s Office, District Attorney Larry Krasner said the office “begins today doing absolutely everything in its power to conduct an independent investigation.” Malayshia’s body was found on Nov. 4 in Lindenwold, New Jersey, and Williams has been charged with murder.
Krasner will lead a team drawn from the office’s Homicide and Non-Fatal Shootings Unit, Special Investigations Unit, Family Violence and Sexual Assault Unit, Victim Services Unit and Trial Division. The release says the focus is potential criminal charges, with the investigation following the evidence into any institutional or systemic failures.
Metro Philadelphia reported that the probe could lead to more charges, or to firings or discipline of child welfare workers for conduct that is not criminal. Krasner also said his office can convene a grand jury.
A former foster child describes life in the home
Maria Campbell says she entered foster care in October 2019 at age 14 and was placed with Williams. She spoke to CBS Philadelphia, which reported her account on Nov. 12.
Campbell alleges that after she took a snack from the kitchen, Williams made her stand for hours writing the same sentence over and over. She also alleges that Williams locked her in her bedroom from the outside and added an alarm system to the door. She says she escaped through a bedroom window in May 2020.
Campbell told the station that the memories are “so vivid” and that she reported what happened but was not heard. She said the caseworkers from the Community Umbrella Agency and the Department of Human Services were not really trying to do anything and made it seem as if she were the problem. She wants to testify at any trial.
Campbell’s account is an allegation from a former foster child, not a court finding. The murder charge is the matter before the court, and Williams is presumed innocent.
The questions about how foster placements work
Philadelphia’s Department of Human Services partners with Community Umbrella Agencies, known as CUAs. The city’s DHS partnerships page says six agencies serve 10 CUA regions and that they “provide ongoing case management to the families involved with the Philadelphia Department of Human Services.”
The DA’s release lists policy questions the review will examine. They include legal representation for children in dependency court, whether child abuse cases should be reviewed regularly by the District Attorney’s Office, police and advocacy groups, and whether the appeals process for the Pennsylvania Child Abuse History Clearance is adequate. Krasner said: “These topics may sound bureaucratic, but they can be part of the solution.”
The Philadelphia Inquirer reported more detail from the news conference. Krasner said the probe would look at funding for court-appointed special advocates, who face high turnover and low pay, and at the kinship laws that decide which relatives can qualify for foster placement. He asked, “Is it all about blood?” The Inquirer also reported that he called the expungement process foster parents used to remove abuse allegations from their records perhaps the most important part of the investigation.
City Council and the mayor respond
On the same Thursday, Councilmembers Anthony Phillips, Kendra Brooks and Cindy Bass introduced three resolutions calling for public hearings on the child welfare system, the Inquirer reported. The resolutions ask committees to examine how DHS monitors children placed outside their homes, how community umbrella agencies manage cases, and whether agencies are doing enough to prevent abuse, neglect and child deaths. One resolution also calls for scrutiny of the School District’s hiring and screening practices. Council President Kenyatta Johnson said “everything is on the table.”
Metro Philadelphia reported that the first hearing is set for 1 p.m. on Friday, Nov. 20, at City Hall, before the Committee on Children and Youth. The paper said Phillips and Brooks tied the case to the 2006 starvation death of Danieal Kelly, a 14-year-old girl who was receiving in-home DHS services.
The Philadelphia Tribune reported that the two councilmembers said the city’s Child Welfare Oversight Board has not held regular meetings in three years. Metro Philadelphia reported that Mayor Cherelle Parker signed an executive order on Tuesday, Nov. 10, forming a committee to examine how DHS coordinates with foster care providers and Community Umbrella Agencies.
Who Williams is and what happens next
Williams, 36, is a teacher at Lewis C. Cassidy Academic Plus School, according to the Philadelphia Tribune. Malayshia, a former fifth grader, had been reported missing for nearly two weeks before her body was found.
Krasner did not say whether anyone else would be charged, the Inquirer reported, and said an update on a relative seen in surveillance video would come soon. The DA’s release asks anyone with information about Williams to contact the Philadelphia Police Department’s Homicide Division.
Parent Diaries covered the first charges in an earlier report on the murder case.
The district attorney’s investigation runs alongside the criminal prosecution of Williams, the mayor’s review committee and the council hearings scheduled to begin Nov. 20.
Get stories like this by email. Sign up for The Parent Diaries Letter.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: John Phelan – CC BY-SA 3.0/Wikimedia Commons
