Elementary school students seated in a classroom during a lesson

A Pediatric Neurologist Says Fourth Grade Is When Many Kids Start Struggling, and She Names 4 Reasons

A child who loved school in third grade starts dragging on school mornings and getting frustrated by homework. Parents may wonder what changed. According to Dr. Shilpa Dass, a pediatric neurologist in New Jersey and mother of three, the answer is often the grade itself.

The jump from third to fourth grade can be one of the hardest transitions of elementary school, Dass told TODAY. She says it is often part of normal growing up, though not every child reacts this way, and she points to 4 reasons it hits so many kids at once.

The signs parents tend to notice first

Kids rarely announce that they are struggling, Dass said. The clues usually show up in behavior instead. Parents may see a child who:

  • resists school mornings or moves slower getting out the door
  • loses enthusiasm for school
  • gets frustrated by homework more easily

Those changes are worth paying attention to, she said, because they are often how a child signals that school has gotten harder.

Reading to learn, and harder words

The first of the 4 reasons, and the biggest shift, Dass said, is in reading. Through third grade, students are mostly learning to read. In fourth grade, they are expected to read to learn, decoding fluently in science, history and even math.

Educators have a name for what can happen next. In a classic study published by the American Federation of Teachers, researchers Jeanne Chall and Vicki Jacobs described a “fourth-grade slump,” when reading scores of children from low-income families began to fall around fourth grade, right at the point where reading becomes a way to learn other subjects. Through second and third grade, those children had performed about as well as other students.

Reading is a challenge for many fourth graders nationwide. On the 2024 Nation’s Report Card, 31% of fourth graders scored at or above Proficient in reading, 2 points lower than in 2022 and 4 points lower than in 2019.

The second reason is vocabulary. Fourth-grade topics are more abstract, and understanding specific words becomes essential. Dass gave the example of a test question that hinges on knowing what “inconclusive” means. A child who can sound out every word may still miss the question.

The AFT study found vocabulary was the first and strongest area to slip. Children could use context clues to get by for a while, the researchers wrote, but comprehension suffered once texts contained too many difficult words. Word recognition and spelling slipped next, and broader comprehension declined later, around sixth and seventh grade.

More independence and shifting friendships

The third reason is independence. Fourth grade is also when many parents and teachers step back. Children are expected to keep track of assignments, remember what is due and organize their own work. That can strain executive functioning, the skills children use to organize and remember tasks, Dass said.

The fourth is social. Friend groups often split into smaller groups around this age, and approval from peers starts to matter more, according to Dass.

What Dass suggests parents do

Her first step is to contact the teacher and compare notes, to pin down exactly where the trouble is.

The American Academy of Pediatrics gives similar advice on its HealthyChildren.org site. It recommends dealing with school problems early, asking the teacher specific questions about what is happening and how often, and agreeing on a follow-up plan before the meeting ends. It also suggests bringing in a counselor, school nurse or the child’s pediatrician when needed.

If reading or vocabulary is the issue, Dass recommends reading aloud together, exposing kids to richer language and talking through unfamiliar words. She also suggests slowing down busy after-school schedules to make room for that time.

For parents heading into a conference about it, the AAP’s guide to parent-teacher conferences suggests writing questions down ahead of time and ranking them, since meetings are often short. It also suggests asking the child what they would like raised, and explaining that the meeting is meant to help, not to criticize. Afterward, the AAP recommends talking with the child about what was agreed and gathering information before any follow-up meeting.

For a fourth grader who suddenly dreads school, Dass’s message is that the struggle is often part of normal growing up, tied to four changes that tend to arrive in the same school year.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: “A forester goes to Buckman Elementary” by Bureau of Land Management Oregon and Washington, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Similar Posts