Alexandrea Duarte and Shawn Richardson Grow Food in Their Front Yard to Feed Their Kids. Their Acworth HOA Calls It ‘Unsightly’ and Is Fining Them $25 a Day.
Peppers, tomatoes and herbs grow in metal troughs in the front yard of Alexandrea Duarte and Shawn Richardson’s home in Acworth, Georgia. The garden helps feed their family on a tight budget, and it sits out front for a practical reason.
Their homeowners association wants it gone. Starting Sept. 28, the couple was charged $25 a day over the steel garden beds, and by late October the balance was approaching $750, according to an Oct. 22 investigation by Atlanta News First.
A Garden Built Around the Kids
Duarte told the station that some of the couple’s children have special dietary needs. Growing their own food helps stretch the family’s money, she said, and it teaches the kids how to be self-sufficient. The family even turns the harvest into holiday gifts, such as pepper jams and basil salts.
Their backyard does not get enough sun for vegetables. That matters for a food garden: University of Georgia Extension horticulturists advise picking a garden site that gets at least 8 to 10 hours of sunlight a day.
Some of the troughs had been in place for nearly two years before the HOA objected. Duarte also added cucumber trellises this year and took them down after summer.
From ‘Please Remove’ to Daily Fines
In June, the community manager sent a notice that read, “Please remove garden from front lawn.” At an appeal meeting that was recorded, the HOA president said the board had received four complaints from separate people.
The association is managed by Community Management Associates, a firm that says it has managed community associations since 1989 and operates in six Southern states. On Oct. 2, CMA emailed Duarte that every galvanized bed had to be removed or the daily fines would continue.
Duarte offered a compromise: take out the newer beds, then paint or surround the older ones, in any color the board chose. CMA rejected it and said the fines would keep coming until all of the beds were gone.
What the Rules Actually Say
The HOA’s rules do not mention gardens at all, Atlanta News First found. They give the board discretion over what counts as “unkept” or “unsightly” and require approval for exterior additions. The HOA president told the station the board has that discretion under the community’s documents.
When the station pressed the CMA manager on which part of the garden was not aesthetically pleasing, the answer was short: “All of it.”
The investigation also found no published fine schedule that set a $25 daily fine. The board removed Duarte from her role as board secretary and asked her to stay away from meetings until the violation is resolved. The HOA and CMA referred questions to their attorney, who did not respond to the station.
Richardson has been venting online. He wrote on Instagram about an organization that will charge a family $25 a day for planting tomatoes without permission, and said a Halloween decoration was the best way to make his point, since yard signs are not allowed.
A New Georgia Law Is Coming in January
The couple has filed a complaint with the Georgia Secretary of State. They hope the state will look at their case once a new law is in force.
Georgia lawmakers passed the Georgia Property Owners’ Bill of Rights Act, Senate Bill 406, earlier this year, and Gov. Brian Kemp signed it on May 12, Atlanta News First reported. The law lets homeowners file complaints with the Secretary of State, with disputes handled by a hearing officer and possible court review. Starting Jan. 1, 2027, associations must register with the state before they can issue fines and fees, and unregistered associations cannot collect them.
The law is not retroactive, according to the station. The Georgia Secretary of State’s office posted a public hearing notice on Nov. 3 for proposed regulations under the Property Owners’ Bill of Rights.
Disputes between families and their HOAs keep surfacing this year, including a North Carolina dad who sued his HOA over his 60,000-light holiday show. For Duarte and Richardson, the question is simpler: whether a few metal troughs of tomatoes and peppers are worth $25 a day.
Get stories like this by email. Sign up for The Parent Diaries Letter.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Kolforn – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons
