Exterior of an elementary school building in California, file photo

A Palo Alto Mom Is Suing Her Son’s School District Over a Third-Grade Report Card Comment About ‘Showing Respect’

Weiwei Luo says one line on her son’s third-grade report card was unfair, and she has taken the Palo Alto Unified School District to court over it. The comment told the boy to keep “showing respect and cooperating with others,” according to Local 12. Luo says it ignored what set off the incident behind it: a classmate had kicked her son first.

A Game of Tag, a Stuck-Out Tongue and One Report Card Line

The Palo Alto Daily Post reported that the dispute traces back to an October 2025 recess at Walter Hays Elementary School. During a game of tag, Luo says, her son stuck his tongue out at a classmate who had kicked him. The boy is a third grader, and Local 12 identifies him only by the initials K.L.

His 2025-2026 report card, written by teacher Holly Harrison according to the suit, said he is “working on his responses to peers when he is frustrated or upset.” Another comment said he was developing his ability to listen to others’ perspectives and collaborate with humility, and a later assessment said he should continue “showing respect and cooperating with others.” Luo argues the teacher never weighed what provoked him.

From a June Request to a 4-0 Board Vote

Local 12, which based its report on court documents obtained by People, laid out the timeline. On June 25, 2026, Luo asked the district to change the comments, calling them inaccurate and unsupported. In July the district revised a section on his academic performance but refused to alter the behavior comments, describing them as the teacher’s professional observations and judgment.

Luo appealed to the Board of Education, which held a hearing on Aug. 18. In her petition, she says assistant superintendent Yolanda Conaway removed her attorney, Marjorie Ouyang, from the board’s virtual meeting, and that the attorney was not told the hearing time. The board denied the appeal 4-0 in closed session. Luo also asked for an audio recording or transcript of the hearing, and the district had neither, the Daily Post reported.

In its written decision, the district said the comments reflected the teacher’s observations, were substantiated and were not misleading in the context of the full report card.

What Luo Is Asking a Judge to Order

Luo sued the district and its Board of Education. She wants the court to overturn the board’s decision, order a new hearing in which her attorney can take part, require the district to correct or remove the comments and reimburse her legal fees and costs. Neither the Daily Post nor Local 12 names the court.

Superintendent Jason Glass told the Daily Post that student privacy laws prevent him from discussing an individual student’s records. He said the district followed the defined process and “will respond to the petition in court.”

How Parents Can Challenge a School Record

California’s Education Code section 49070 lets a parent ask the superintendent in writing to correct or remove information in a student’s record that is inaccurate, misleading or an unsupported conclusion. The superintendent must meet with the parent within 30 days, and a parent whose request is refused can appeal to the governing board within 30 days. The board decides in closed session, and the statute says its decision is final.

The federal Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act sets a parallel route. Under the regulations summarized by the U.S. Department of Education, a parent may bring a representative, including an attorney, to a hearing at the parent’s own expense, and a school that upholds a record must let the parent add a statement commenting on it. The department’s parent guide to FERPA adds a limit: the amendment right covers factual errors, not substantive judgments such as grades or other performance evaluations.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Missvain – CC0/Wikimedia Commons

Similar Posts