A home DNA testing kit with a saliva collection tube

Kathy Gillcrist Was Adopted in the 1950s. A 23andMe Test Revealed Her Birth Father Is a Fugitive Who Was on the FBI’s Ten Most Wanted List.

Kathy Gillcrist checked a box when she sent in her 23andMe sample in 2017. It said she was adopted and open to hearing more. About six weeks later the results came back, and soon after, a cousin she had never met got in touch. That contact, WXII reported, eventually led the North Carolina woman, adopted in the 1950s, to the name of her birth father.

A cousin, a genealogist and a name to look up

The cousin who reached out after the results became a close contact. About eight months later, WXII reported, that cousin, a genealogist, helped Gillcrist identify her biological father.

The name was William Bradford Bishop, and the cousin suggested she look him up. Gillcrist had hoped her father would turn out to be someone famous. She reacted with shock and laughter, she told the station.

The match came through 23andMe’s DNA Relatives feature, which is optional. 23andMe’s support page says other users cannot see a customer as a match unless that customer opts in, and that matches show a predicted relationship and the percentage of DNA shared. Customers can also change what relatives see about them, including their display name, in their privacy settings.

That opt-in design is why a single test can reach relatives who never knew the person existed. The cousin who contacted Gillcrist was one of those matches, and the genealogy work that followed did the rest.

Who William Bradford Bishop is

Bishop is accused of killing his wife, his mother and his three sons at their home in Bethesda, Maryland, in 1976. Gillcrist was a college freshman at the time, WXII reported. According to the station, he is also accused of driving to North Carolina, burning the bodies and abandoning his car before he disappeared.

The FBI’s wanted page still lists him as wanted for the killings. In a 2015 FBI Baltimore release, the bureau said the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Maryland had charged him with unlawful flight to avoid prosecution in the murders. The release gave the ages of his sons as 14, 10 and 5.

The release said investigators had followed more than 480 leads in a year and received tips from several countries, none of which led to Bishop. It also said investigators identified Bishop’s DNA from a cigarette butt found in the family station wagon in 1976 and have been comparing his profile against databases worldwide.

The search has included checking lookalike reports at grocery stores, neighborhood bars, truck stops and a bridge club, according to the release. Investigators exhumed a man killed in a 1981 car accident, and DNA testing showed it was not Bishop. They also tested a man found dead off the coast of Mexico, who was not Bishop either.

The murders remain unsolved, and Bishop has never been found, WXII reported. The case is still open, and he would be about 90 now.

What the FBI list says today

The FBI added Bishop to its Ten Most Wanted Fugitives list on April 10, 2014. WXII dates the addition to April 2014, and the FBI’s own Ten Most Wanted history page gives the exact date. An FBI podcast page notes that Bishop took the spot of Juan Garcia, who surrendered to the FBI one day after being added.

The FBI history page also shows Bishop was removed from the list on June 27, 2018, because he no longer met the list’s criteria. Removal from the list does not close the case. The FBI’s wanted page still seeks him, and he remains a fugitive.

WXII’s report, published Nov. 12, describes him as on the list. The FBI’s records show he came off it more than seven years ago, so this article describes him as a fugitive who was once on it.

What Gillcrist has done with the discovery

Gillcrist researched her father extensively, including his journal entries, and published a book, It’s In My Genes, during the pandemic, WXII reported. Her story went viral, she built a working relationship with the FBI, and she has received tips from around the world. Reported sightings have mostly been in Europe, though photo sightings have slowed in recent years.

She told WXII the more she learns about him, the scarier it is. She also said that once a person learns information that is true, it cannot be taken back.

Gillcrist has said she would be open to meeting Bishop if he is found, as long as she would be safe. In the 2015 release, FBI Baltimore’s Special Agent in Charge Steve Vogt said the public’s calls and emails were essential to the search, and Montgomery County Sheriff Darren Popkin said every lead continues to be thoroughly investigated. The bureau listed 1-800-CALL-FBI and tips.fbi.gov for anyone with information.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Tony Webster, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Similar Posts