The Idaho State Capitol building in Boise, where lawmakers passed the state's safe haven law

Suzanne Hobbs Reported on a Baby Found in an Idaho Dumpster and Pushed for a Safe Haven Law. Two Years Later, a Baby Left Under It Became Her Daughter.

On an October morning in 2000, Suzanne Hobbs was starting her day as a television bureau chief in Idaho Falls when a police sergeant she knew called with a tip. A man collecting cans from dumpsters had found what he thought was a doll. It was the body of a newborn boy.

Hobbs covered that story, then helped push for a law so it wouldn’t happen again. About two years later, a baby girl surrendered under that law became her daughter. Hobbs, now director of media relations at the National Safe Haven Alliance, told the story in a first-person essay for Newsweek published in September.

The alley behind the crime scene tape

Hobbs wrote that police had strung tape across a gravel alley. A detective climbed into a yellow dumpster and handed a small bundle wrapped in towels to a man, who put it in a funeral home van and drove away.

Investigators learned that an 18-year-old woman had hidden her pregnancy from her father and brother, delivered the baby alone in the family bathroom and left him in the dumpster. An autopsy suggested he had never taken a breath.

At the time, Hobbs and her husband had been married seven years. They had been trying for a baby and had just been told they would never conceive.

A grieving grandfather’s question

When Hobbs interviewed the young woman’s father, he raised an idea: a safe haven law that would let a parent hand over a newborn legally. Idaho didn’t have one. He wondered aloud whether his daughter would have made a different choice if she had known she could leave the baby at a fire station a few blocks away.

Hobbs called State Sen. Bart Davis, whom she had interviewed many times. He sponsored a bill, and she kept reporting on it as it moved through the Idaho House and Senate. In the spring of 2001, the law was signed at a fire station in Idaho Falls. Then-Gov. Dirk Kempthorne called Hobbs forward during the ceremony and handed her one of the signing pens.

That law still stands. Under Section 39-8203 of the Idaho Safe Haven Act, a parent can leave a baby no more than 30 days old with a safe haven, and that safe haven must keep the parent’s identity confidential. It may not ask who the parent is, and the parent is protected from prosecution for abandonment. The legislature’s history notes show the section was first added in 2001 and was amended as recently as 2025. The full chapter is posted on the Idaho Legislature’s website.

The phone call that made her a mother

About two years after the law passed, the same police sergeant called Hobbs again. A woman had given birth to a baby girl at a hospital and left a handwritten note surrendering her under the safe haven law. The sergeant knew about Hobbs’s role in the law, and he knew she and her husband hoped to adopt.

Hobbs left messages for their adoption caseworker all afternoon and heard nothing back. The couple went to bed believing the baby would go to another family. The next morning, as they were heading out the door for work, the phone rang. Her husband answered questions about a baby girl, a car seat and a name.

They named her Lillie, after Hobbs’s grandmother Lillian, who had died six weeks earlier. The baby weighed 5 pounds, 3 ounces. Hobbs wrote that she likes to say she became a mother in a phone call.

Meeting the woman who chose the hospital

Lillie always knew she was adopted. Hobbs wrote that she explained it to her daughter in simple terms: her own “tummy” was broken, and a kind woman, Lillie’s “tummy mommy,” had shared her.

When Lillie was 16, a DNA match led the family to her birth mother, Laina. Hobbs told Lillie she could meet Laina whenever she felt ready, and a few weeks later, she was. Laina has since been at Lillie’s graduation and her 18th birthday, and Lillie has met several half-sisters.

The story has an echo in Indiana, where Addison Koie, the first baby surrendered under Vigo County’s safe haven program, was adopted by a mom who had struggled for years with infertility.

What Hobbs wants every teenager to know

Safe haven laws now exist in all 50 states, Hobbs wrote, but the rules differ from state to state, including how many days after birth a baby can be surrendered. The National Safe Haven Alliance notes that each state has its own law.

Hobbs argues that students in grades 7 through 12 should spend five minutes a year learning their state’s law. She also wrote that surrender isn’t always the answer: callers to the alliance’s crisis line who want to keep their babies are connected with support and resources instead.

The National Safe Haven Alliance, a nonprofit, runs that crisis line 24 hours a day at 1-888-510-BABY (2229), by call or text. In an emergency, the group says to call 911.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Indies1 – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

Similar Posts