A fenced residential backyard with a playground

Michael and Lisa Newman Won $200,000 From Their HOA Over a Fence for Their Autistic Kids. Now They’re Suing 33 Neighbors Who Still Owe $1,350 Each.

A fence request that began in 2019 is still in court in De Pere, Wisconsin. Michael and Lisa Newman, who have five children, some of them with autism, won a $200,000 settlement from their homeowners association. In September they filed a new lawsuit against the association and 33 residents who have not paid their share, Realtor.com reported in a story that ran on Yahoo.

The association filed its answer on November 16. Its contents were not public when the story was published.

Two Requests With No Answer

The Newmans live in the Nazcr Trac neighborhood. In July 2019 they asked the Nazcr Trac Property Owners Association for an exception to its no-fence rule, according to Realtor.com. Some of their children have autism, and two were described as having a significant risk of elopement, a term for wandering away from a safe place.

They asked again in December 2020, this time pointing to the association’s legal duty to consider an accommodation. Realtor.com reported that neither request was answered.

NBC 26 in Green Bay, in a report carried by TMJ4, said the board had cited a covenant in the neighborhood’s 2001 plat map stating that no fences of any kind would be allowed.

From Federal Court to a Fence

In August 2021 the Newmans sued in federal court, claiming disability discrimination under the Fair Housing Amendments Act. The federal Department of Justice says the Fair Housing Act makes it unlawful to refuse reasonable accommodations in land use and zoning that people with disabilities need to use and enjoy housing equally.

In May 2022, federal District Judge William Griesbach granted the family a preliminary injunction, according to the published court order. Realtor.com reported that the injunction barred the association from enforcing its rule, and that the family built the fence that summer.

The $200,000 and the $1,350 Bills

In August 2024, the association agreed to pay the Newmans $200,000, Realtor.com reported. The cost was passed on to each household in the neighborhood, at $1,350 per property.

Not everyone paid right away. By January 2025, NBC 26 reported that 56 homeowners had paid, one of them for two plots, and that nearly 40 homes had not. Some owners said they did not believe they were required to pay.

Realtor.com reported that 69 homeowners settled after the first lawsuit, according to the Newmans’ attorney. The new filing names the association and 33 residents, for 34 defendants in all. In a November 13 report, NBC 26 quoted the attorney as saying 55 homeowners still owe money.

What Each Side Has Said

The Newmans’ attorney, Victoria Davis Davila, told WGBA, “There’s an outstanding judgment.” She said neighbors had the chance to pay and chose not to, and that the Newmans want to put the matter behind them. She also said the association’s membership could be held liable if the amount is not paid.

Lisa Newman told WGBA she felt “not great” about neighbors paying, called it an unfortunate situation for everyone and said the board made the decision for everybody.

Some residents have said the neighborhood was never asked. One resident told WGBA in 2025 that most neighbors would have had no issue with the fence and that the board should have polled members. Another homeowner called it unfair that the matter had come back to them.

Realtor.com said it contacted legal counsel for both the association and the Newmans and had received no response. NBC 26 said its report included no official statement from the association.

Where the Case Stands

Realtor.com gave the new case number as 2026CV001405 in Wisconsin’s circuit court system and did not name the court. Nothing has been decided in the new lawsuit, and the association’s defense has not been made public.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Infrogmation of New Orleans – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

Similar Posts